This Kaiser Well being Information story could be republished totally free (details).
Early final winter, Pfizer launched its new rheumatoid arthritis remedy, Inflectra, pricing it 15 % under the $four,000-a-dose wholesale worth of Remicade, the drug for which it’s a shut copy.
Pfizer figured its lower cost would appeal to value-acutely aware insurers.
A yr later, although, its drug has barely scratched the market and Pfizer has filed an antitrust suit towards its rivals, alleging they’re thwarting decrease-priced competitors via “exclusionary contracts” and rebates.
The result of the case — filed in September in U.S. District Courtroom towards Johnson & Johnson, the maker of Remicade, and Janssen Biotech — might have an effect on the way forward for biosimilars, a brand new class of medicine. Some coverage specialists say these close to-copies of biologics are key to slowing spending on complicated and costly specialty drugs like these used to deal with rheumatoid arthritis.
On the coronary heart of the case are rebates, that are reductions off the wholesale worth of medicine.
Producers supply them to assist maintain their merchandise on insurers’ lists of coated medicine. The cash primarily goes again to insurers and pharmacy profit managers, who say the rebates assist scale back well being care spending.
However Pfizer alleges that these rebates are getting used to thwart biosimilars’ entry into the marketplace.
“That is the primary antitrust case we’ve seen like this round biosimilars,” stated Michael Service, a Rutgers Regulation Faculty professor “Pfizer is claiming that one type of anti-aggressive conduct includes withholding rebates from insurers.”
Subscribe to KHN’s free Morning Briefing.
Please affirm your e mail handle under:
Biosimilars are pricey to supply, so they don’t seem to be more likely to set off the identical sharp pricing drop triggered by generics. Nonetheless, their producers say they might deliver shoppers some aid to rival biologics’ excessive worth tags.
Pfizer’s Inflectra is likely one of the first biosimilars to hit the market since Congress handed laws in 2010 to pave the best way.
In response to Pfizer, weeks after Inflectra gained Meals and Drug Admininstration approval, J&J moved to stake out its biologic turf.
J&J started requiring insurers and PBMs to signal “exclusionary contracts … designed to dam each insurers from reimbursing and hospitals and clinics from buying Inflectra or different biosimilars of Remicade regardless of their decrease pricing,” alleges the case filed in federal district courtroom in Philadelphia.
If insurers don’t comply with the J&J contracts, the lack of rebates might “for some insurers, run into the tens of hundreds of thousands of dollars yearly,” the Pfizer case alleges.
Even with its lower cost, Pfizer confronted an uphill battle to win market share.
Remicade is the fifth-largest-promoting drug by income within the U.S., reaping greater than $four.eight billion in 2016 for makers J&J and Janssen, the go well with stated. Typically, sufferers are reluctant to modify as soon as they’re established on an RA drug that’s working for them.
Nonetheless, Pfizer thought it will decide up newly recognized sufferers and achieve floor that approach. However its lawsuit says the drug accounted for less than about four % of complete gross sales, with Remicade getting the remaining, by early September.
“We stand by our contracts,” stated J&J and Janssen Biotech in a written statement. The companies additionally defend rebates as “competitors that’s doing what competitors is supposed to do: driving deeper reductions that may result in general decrease prices.”
But the worth of Remicade has not fallen, the Pfizer case says.
Since approval of Inflectra, J&J has raised the listing worth of Remicade by near 9 %, the lawsuit alleges. As of September, Remicade’s common gross sales worth –after reductions and rebates — is greater than 10 % larger than Inflectra.
“This case is an enormous deal, as a result of it has the potential to deliver to mild a number of the anti-aggressive contracting practices at work to maintain … costs extraordinarily excessive,” stated Jaime King, a professor at College of California-Hastings School of the Regulation.
Kaiser Health News (KHN) is a nationwide well being coverage information service. It’s an editorially unbiased program of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation which isn’t affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.